I agree with most of your post, but I have to point out that Hitler >>declared war on the US on Dec 11, 1941. Hitler was also sinking US ships >>that were carrying supplies to Britain.
True but, if the US had also not been involved in WWI, I am wondering if
the attitude towards the US would have been different. Germany was
destroyed by the concessions they made during their WWI surrender. To an >extent, I feel like they were out for revenge against all of the countries >that put them in that position.
Still, with the U-boats patrolling the whole North Atlantic (and likely,
the Gulf of Mexico), conflict of some degree was inevitable, as you noted >below.
Note that Roosevelt minor had the US Navy involved in World War II long >>before the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor. The "Greer Incident," where
the US destroyer Greer was fired on by a U-Boat, occurred because the
Greer had detected the U-Boat and radioed for British aircraft (from >>Canada) to come and bomb it. The U-Boat captain had no idea who'd
dropped the bomb/depth charges and the only ship around was the Greer.
This sort of thing was quite common in 1940-1941
The US was also secretly involved supporting China against Japan long
before Pearl Harbor. WWII actually started in 1937 when Japan escalated >their aggressions against China by invading Shanghai and other areas. The
US supported China with supplies and, I believe, volunteers (like The
Flying Tigers).
Many believe that Pearl Harbor was unprovoked, but I have often wondered if
Japan did not figure out that the US was not being as neutral as we claimed to be.
LL> >Iran better choose their choose their actions with extreme calculation, a
LL> > must don't attack any American military, if they do it will be curtains
LL> > Iran. Permanently I am afraid.... According the Presidents tweets.
LL>
LL> Do you honestly believe anybody pays any attention to
LL> the presidents tweets? The democratically elected leader
LL> of Venezuela certainly doesn't. And neither does the tinhorn
LL> dictator of North Korea. Or the democratically elected leader
LL> of Russia. Or the president-for-life of China. So what makes
LL> you think the mullahs of Iran pay any attention?
He got someone's attention in Iran, they are not firing any more rockets
into
Iraq nor are they attacking the U.S. Forces in the waterways that is close
to
Iran. They got the message that if attacked The United States will end you.
Hello Greg,
LL> >Iran better choose their choose their actions with extreme calculation, a
LL> > must don't attack any American military, if they do it will be curtains
LL> > Iran. Permanently I am afraid.... According the Presidents tweet
LL>
LL> Do you honestly believe anybody pays any attention to
LL> the presidents tweets? The democratically elected leader
LL> of Venezuela certainly doesn't. And neither does the tinhorn
LL> dictator of North Korea. Or the democratically elected leader
LL> of Russia. Or the president-for-life of China. So what makes
LL> you think the mullahs of Iran pay any attention?
that is closeHe got someone's attention in Iran, they are not firing any more rockets
into LL> >Iraq nor are they attacking the U.S. Forces in the waterways
to
Iran. They got the message that if attacked The United States will end yo
You may not be aware of this, but Trump ordered 4 out of our 5
aircraft carriers to enter inside the Persian Gulf, in an effort
to intimidate Iran.
Iran does have missiles capable of sinking an aircraft carrier,
along with underwater torpedoes. What do you think the reaction
would be if just one of our aircraft carriers was hit, or sunk?
You are talking 5,000+ dead American sailors.
This would be a debacle, much worse than the events of 9-11.
On 22 May 2019, BOB ACKLEY said the following...curtains
Iran better choose their choose their actions with extremecalculation, and
must don't attack any American military, if they do it will be
Iran. Permanently I am afraid.... According the Presidents tweets.
Maybe. But I hope nothing happens there
That would depend how suicidal the Iranian Government is.
I agree with most of your post, but I have to point out that Hitler declared war on the US on Dec 11, 1941. Hitler was also sinking US ships that were carrying supplies to Britain.
True but, if the US had also not been involved in WWI, I am wondering if
the attitude towards the US would have been different. Germany was
destroyed by the concessions they made during their WWI surrender. To an extent, I feel like they were out for revenge against all of the countries that put them in that position.
That would depend how suicidal the Iranian Government is.
That the US military could destroy the Iranian government is a given.
But it would cost one h*ll of a lot of lives (on both sides), and the
Iran will try probably succeed to some extent - to make it a war of the US Islam, and ALL Islamics are required by their religion to respond to any attack.
You may not be aware of this, but Trump ordered 4 out of our 5
aircraft carriers to enter inside the Persian Gulf, in an effort
to intimidate Iran.
More of like message written in big block style letters, lets call it a
strong persuasion that says Peace through Strength.
Iran does have missiles capable of sinking an aircraft carrier,
along with underwater torpedoes. What do you think the reaction
would be if just one of our aircraft carriers was hit, or sunk?
You are talking 5,000+ dead American sailors.
It would be suicidal to attack the U.S. forces.
It would be a mis-calulation, that would cost them their very existence.
Iran would be nothing more then a memory.
This would be a debacle, much worse than the events of 9-11.
Nothing is worse then 9-11
Hello Greg,
[..]
You may not be aware of this, but Trump ordered 4 out of our 5 >LL>aircraft carriers to enter inside the Persian Gulf, in an effort >LL>to intimidate Iran.
More of like message written in big block style letters, lets call it a
strong persuasion that says Peace through Strength.
That did not work out so well in Afghanistan, where we are still
stuck with no way to get out. That also did not work out so well
in Iraq, which continues to be a snake pit. We need another war
in that area of the world like we need a hole in the head.
Iran does have missiles capable of sinking an aircraft carrier, >LL>along with underwater torpedoes. What do you think the reaction >LL>would be if just one of our aircraft carriers was hit, or sunk? >LL>You are talking 5,000+ dead American sailors.
It would be suicidal to attack the U.S. forces.
Osama bin Laden and his merry group of al-Qaeda did it for years.
GWB allowed him and his merry men to escape Afghanistan. Thank
goodness we had a man from Kenya who saved our ass by actually
having the balls to "terminate with extreme prejudice" that piece
of shit.
It would be a mis-calulation, that would cost them their very existence.
Iran would be nothing more then a memory.
Would it? Jimmy Carter got our embassy personnel home safe and sound, without resorting to war with Iran. How many American lives is Trump willing to waste by going to war with Iran for no reason?
There is a sunken German U-boat just off the coast of Grand Isle,
Louisiana. I was invited to take part in a scuba expedition to try
to salvage parts. But the German government stopped us from doing
so, claiming it was protected by international law, being a gravesite
for those who had perished. Whether there was gold bullion inside
or not, we never were able to find out ...
The US was also secretly involved supporting China against Japan long >before Pearl Harbor. WWII actually started in 1937 when Japan escalated >their aggressions against China by invading Shanghai and other areas. The
US supported China with supplies and, I believe, volunteers (like The Flying Tigers).
Unfortunately, the US supported the wrong China, refusing to
recognize the other China as legitimate. It took Jimmy Carter
to change that, many decades later.
In Japan's view, it was just a warning to the US to stay out of
the Pacific. A limited strike by Japanese military on a US military installation in a US territory, not on civilian targets or in the
mainland USA. A pinprick, which the Japanese military leadership
calculated would be enough to convince FDR to stay out.
The outcry among the American public forced FDR and the Congress
to accept the reality that the US was in a war, started by the
Empire of Japan. Leaving no choice for FDR and the Congress but
to do what none of them were brave enough to do themselves.
True but, if the US had also not been involved in WWI, I am wondering if the attitude towards the US would have been different. Germany was destroyed by the concessions they made during their WWI surrender. To an extent, I feel like they were out for revenge against all of the countries that put them in that position.
Actually, what happened is that the German goverment continued its
generous social spending programs after WW I. Unfortunately the war reparations demanded by the Allies pretty much destroyed the German
economy. In about 1922 or 1923 the German economy collapsed due to
rampant (100 percent per DAY) inflation, and with it went the German government. That provided an avenue for Hitler to get into power.
Would it? Jimmy Carter got our embassy personnel home safe and sound, without resorting to war with Iran. How many American lives is Trump
willing to waste by going to war with Iran for no reason?
Would it? Jimmy Carter got our embassy personnel home safe and sound, without resorting to war with Iran. How many American lives is Trump willing to waste by going to war with Iran for no reason?
No he did not.
On 05-27-19 13:11, Mike Powell <=-
spoke to Lee Lofaso about Iran <=-
Would it? Jimmy Carter got our embassy personnel home safe and sound, without resorting to war with Iran.
No he did not.
Would it? Jimmy Carter got our embassy personnel home safe and sound, >>without resorting to war with Iran. How many American lives is Trump >>willing to waste by going to war with Iran for no reason?
No he did not.
Would it? Jimmy Carter got our embassy personnel home safe and sound, >>without resorting to war with Iran. How many American lives is Trump >>willing to waste by going to war with Iran for no reason?
No he did not.
longThe US was also secretly involved supporting China against Japan
before Pearl Harbor.
onlyUnfortunately, the US supported the wrong China, refusing to
recognize the other China as legitimate. It took Jimmy Carter
to change that, many decades later.
Not back then. They had been in a Civil War, but had set aside their differences to join together to fight the Japanese. There was still
one China until later.getting
In Japan's view, it was just a warning to the US to stay out of
the Pacific. A limited strike by Japanese military on a US military installation in a US territory, not on civilian targets or in the
mainland USA. A pinprick, which the Japanese military leadership calculated would be enough to convince FDR to stay out.
I have always found that odd, since we did not seem too keen on
involved. They really miscalculated there.
The outcry among the American public forced FDR and the Congress
to accept the reality that the US was in a war, started by the
Empire of Japan. Leaving no choice for FDR and the Congress but
to do what none of them were brave enough to do themselves.
No disagreement there.
Mike
---
* SLMR 2.1a * Acid absorbs 10 times its weight in excess reality.
* Origin: capitolcityonline.net * Telnet/SSH:2022/HTTP (1:2320/105)
wondering ifTrue but, if the US had also not been involved in WWI, I am
wasthe attitude towards the US would have been different. Germany
surrender. To andestroyed by the concessions they made during their WWI
countriesextent, I feel like they were out for revenge against all of the
reparations).that put them in that position.
Actually, what happened is that the German goverment continued its
generous social spending programs after WW I. Unfortunately the war reparations demanded by the Allies pretty much destroyed the German economy. In about 1922 or 1923 the German economy collapsed due to
rampant (100 percent per DAY) inflation, and with it went the German government. That provided an avenue for Hitler to get into power.
IIRC, Hitler blamed the German government (for the social programs and
other spending habits) and the WWI allies (for the crippling
Either way, if the US had not been involved, he might not have been so willing to drag the US into the European conflict. Then again, hisleaders
paranoia might have lead him to do so anyway. When you deal with
that are not in their right minds, who knows?
Hello Greg,
[..]
You may not be aware of this, but Trump ordered 4 out of our 5 >LL>aircraft carriers to enter inside the Persian Gulf, in an effort >LL>to intimidate Iran.
More of like message written in big block style letters, lets call it a
strong persuasion that says Peace through Strength.
That did not work out so well in Afghanistan, where we are still
stuck with no way to get out. That also did not work out so well
in Iraq, which continues to be a snake pit. We need another war
in that area of the world like we need a hole in the head.
Iran does have missiles capable of sinking an aircraft carrier, >LL>along with underwater torpedoes. What do you think the reaction >LL>would be if just one of our aircraft carriers was hit, or sunk? >LL>You are talking 5,000+ dead American sailors.
It would be suicidal to attack the U.S. forces.
Osama bin Laden and his merry group of al-Qaeda did it for years.
GWB allowed him and his merry men to escape Afghanistan. Thank
goodness we had a man from Kenya who saved our ass by actually
having the balls to "terminate with extreme prejudice" that piece
of shit.
Sysop: | Coz |
---|---|
Location: | Anoka, MN |
Users: | 2 |
Nodes: | 4 (0 / 4) |
Uptime: | 71:43:44 |
Calls: | 359 |
Files: | 6,267 |
Messages: | 235,581 |